The Twilight Sad – Live, Edinburgh Liquid Room, Thursday 20th March 2008

I didn’t just come for the Twilight Sad tonight, because two other highly promising Scottish bands were on the bill as well – Eagleowl and Make Model. As usual, promo company I Fly Spitfires pay attention to the whole lineup, not just the headline act.
Eagleowl I know a little about, seeing as a regular reader of mine, Bart, is in the band. I have heard some their dark, shimmering folk on their MySpace page of course, but I’ve held off writing about them since I found out that they were playing this gig. Music like this plays particularly well live. The deep, morose double bass and mournful, agitated violin play off against each other at a tortuously slow pace, counterpointed wonderfully by the interplay of Bart and Clarissa’s vocals. It’s dark music for the most part, but the vocals lift it really nicely, although something in me almost feels they should have played after the Twilight Sad, as we all wound down with a whiskey.
Eagleowl – Know by Now
Make Model were, unfortunately disappointing. They had a couple of catchy enough tunes, but for the kind of money that’s been thrown at them I was expecting to hear something more obviously special. Still, I’m sure I’ll hear them again so I may yet change my mind.
I knew exactly what to expect from The Twilight Sad, however. Menacing guitars that shimmer and grind, cranking up to one monumental wall of noise after another, all accompanied by James Graham’s anguished howl. Their album, Fourteen Autumns and Fifteen Winters was one of my favourite releases of 2007, and the only time I saw them play last year was one of my favourite gigs.
There’s something euphoric about this kind of thunderous blitzkrieg of a racket charging at you from the stage. I am not much of a mosh-pit monkey myself, I just like to stand about two-thirds of the way back and gently bounce and sway as bands like this thunder away at us. It’s not a physical experience in the exhausted, sweaty sense, more a spiritual one, in a profound stillness of experience sense.
There’s something quite fantastic about standing there doing little more than bending in the gale, like reeds in a storm, as the music swirls all around you. I came out the gig giddy and excited, buzzing and eager. Great stuff. The new songs sounded good, the old ones sounded great and all in all, this was one of the best gig nights I’ve been to in quite a while. And as for the acapella intro to Cold Days From the Birdhouse, well… sheer spine-tingling magic.
The Twilight Sad – And She Would Darken the Memory
The Twilight Sad – I’m Taking the Train Home

dammit. knew there was something i meant to do on friday night.
sounded like a bit of a blinder…
I love their album too matthew – but that’s my third time seeing them live and they never ever capture the delicate touches contained in the album. once again I was left slightly bored.. the wall of noise just doesn’t work for me – the tunes are lost within it and the songs do not breathe in my opinion. third time seeing them, third time leaving disappointed.
I loved the Twilight Sad when I saw them, though Euan’s not the first to be bored by them live. Ah well. Speaking of ‘em, where are these new songs you’ve mentioned? I’m aching for a new release, it feels like forever since the last one.
By the way, happy to see that James Graham still wears a cardigan well…
Well Euan I know that’s not the first time I’ve heard that criticism either. A friend of mine recently said that he heard them live and that in this particular instance the volume just wasn’t as fierce as usual. His take on it was that when they don’t blow you away with the amount of noise they create then their songs don’t stand up all that well.
It’s also worth noting that their album is something of a labour of love: layer after layer was apparently added to the music to create something much more textured than you’re ever going to hear at a gig.
That said, I still loved it. I love their tunes, I love his voice, and I loved the infernal racket they made.
kind of suggests that they care more about the live sound than the album sound – which is a shame cause it’s fucking brilliant. and i do love their tunes and his voice but live they just kill everything which I thought was brilliant about the album. which for me is a shame. can understand why people love it live – but it feels tuneless and just a noise for the sake of it. for me anyways and again i stress that i do love their album!
I too was bitterly disappointed with Make Model when I saw them a few weeks back in Glagow.
Despite being top of the bill, they were nowhere near as good as Popup or We Were Promised Jetpacks.