No, we’re not doing that this week actually, although Five Ways to Leave Your Lover would be a fine Friday Five at some point in the future. Nothing too insulting, nothing too pedestrian, and points given for believability combined with strangeness. Nice idea actually but, well, maybe later.
This week’s five were suggested by the excellent Mr. Team Turnip on the Pains of Being Pure at Heart review, I think. It was all about bands who develop their songwriting and those who simply consolidate once they have found a style with which they and their fans are comfortable.
This is a nice one actually, because it exposes our prejudices. The sum total of all music criticism pretty much boils down to ‘I like this… and I don’t like that.’ It’s an instinctive decision and as much as we can try and rationalise it afterwards, no amount of good argument can make you like or dislike anything much more than you do instinctively. I suppose being pointed out that something was ripped off from somewhere or that such and such is a dickhead or so on can make you cool on something, but basically I think we’re mostly left with just a gut reaction, as far as music is concerned.
So for all we praise bands for developing, complain that they are derivative or criticise them for standing still, there are always plenty of groups we love who make total hypocrites of us for doing so. So chip in with yours, please, and take this opportunity not to worry about the fact that 90% of the comments on this site come from the same ten or fifteen people. Ignore them, they’re harmless, and I’d be delighted to be introduced to a new lurker, should you fancy it. Take the plunge, the water’s lovely.
1. Band who just knock out the same old shit time after time, but you love them anyway.
2. Band who have impressed you by continuing to develop, despite having a lot to lose.
3. Band who have become better and better with time.
4. Band who are a total rip-off, but you don’t fucking care, thank you very much.
5. Band you love who make you feel like a total hypocrite.