Song, by Toad

avatar

Why Remixes Make Me Hate Music

 See that image on the right, there?  That’s the egg of what is known as a cowbird, a bird which, a little like a cuckoo, tricks other birds into raising its young and therefore is able to avoid doing any fucking work itself.

I hope you can see how I would think this a suitable image to illustrate a rant about fucking remixers.

I was actually intending to use a picture of a parasite to illustrate this particular post but, honestly, I couldn’t stomach the Google image search.  It would have more accurately illustrated how I feel though. I also did a search for ‘attention whore’, but the results were almost as unpalatable.  Perez/Paris Hilton or a fucking tapeworm, which would you rather gaze at a picture of?  You see why I went for the eggs.

To make matters even worse, as much as I have been driven to despise the epidemic of cack-handed, attention-whoring remixes which infest the fucking internet like a nasty dose of the crabs, remixes are not something I think are inherently bad.  In fact, there may not be many, but there are at least some remixes which I think are brilliant. 

And as much as my chief whinge about remixes is largely based around accusations of parasitism and attention whoring, I am not foolish enough to entirely dismiss remixing music as a skill – not least by the obvious test which excuses a similar accusation that DJing is just like a playlist plus cross-fade: if it can be done badly, which it very clearly can, then you cannot possibly deny that it is therefore indeed a skill, so I don’t lack respect for remixing which is done well.

And to continue in mitigation, the remix also serves a really nice social function amongst musicians too.  I know loads of musicians who swap around remixing duties with one another’s music, partly as a way of working with people they respect, partly out of sheer fascination in what will be done with their music, and partly as a sort of tangential way of making connections which bind their communities together.

And, to reiterate, I have heard some fantastically good remixes.

But I have heard so, so many hundreds which are shite.  Not just shite, but embarrassing shite.  And, the worst, and the reason for this rant, not just shite, not just embarrassing shite, but embarrassing shite done solely for the purpose of cynical attention whoring and parasitically exploiting someone else’s success.  And the fact that this latter category seems to far, far outweigh any of the former in the volume with which it is ejaculated and the shrillness with which it demands our ears is the chief reason remixes have slowly but surely made me come to despise music.

For those who do not know it, The Hype Machine is not just ‘a’ but probably ‘the’ music blog aggregator.  When it first started out mp3 blogs were relatively few and far between, so aggregating them all made sense, and the Hype Machine’s chart was a relatively significant chart of what those people mental enough to spend all day writing about music for no obvious benefit to themselves. A song I posted by an unknown band from Norwich called Bambi Get Over It stubbornly stayed at the top of the chart for days back in 2008, despite precisely zero PR effort, just because people liked it that much.

Bambi Get Over It – Badman

Audio clip: Adobe Flash Player (version 9 or above) is required to play this audio clip. Download the latest version here. You also need to have JavaScript enabled in your browser.

Slowly but surely, as the mainstream music press both collapsed and developed appalling tunnel vision, music blogs became more or less the one place people who were into ‘alternative’ music of any stripe went to find the stuff, and consequently the Hype Machine became a big fucking deal.  However, people soon learned that certain keywords would be searched for regularly on the Hype Machine and because of the way the front page acted like a ticker of what every mp3 blogger out there was posting, there were certain ways to game the system.

It got to the point a few years ago where we music bloggers were openly taking the piss out of Anthony who runs the Hype Machine by pointing out that, balls to actual musical relevance, crapping out a remix of a Radiohead cover was the obvious and inexorable way to get to the top of the Hype Machine chart.  The charts were fucking infested with fucking awful remixes.

Now, the guys at the Hype Machine put a lot of work into making sure their chart is highly relevant of course, and not just PR fodder or remix attention whoring, so at the time and on numerous occasions since they have seriously tweaked how they calculated their chart to make sure this kind of thing doesn’t happen.

This was more of a problem in the US of course, because their mainstream press collapsed much more than ours here in the UK, and that which remains is still for the most part hopelessly afflicted with tunnel vision.  Blogs have never really had the same prominence here, so to a degree we escaped this problem… until Twitter and fucking Facebook.

Now what was a problem for the Hype Machine is no-one’s problem at all.  Do either Facebook or Twitter care how much utter garbage people’s feeds are clogged up with?  No, of course not, they just care that you have them, what’s in them is your problem.  But the old trick of gaming the information-feed-rubbernecking habits of the human animal is still just as effective.

Back then it was Radiohead, but the very second I heard the term ‘Lana Del Rey remix’ it was pretty fucking obvious what would cause me to mash my head against the desk the most in the early months of 2012.  Now, Lana Del Rey herself is someone I already despise for being an attention whore – it is the single characteristic which most consistently defines her career thus far – but at least she is using her own tunes and her own image, depressing as it may be, to get us to glance her way for a few minutes.

The countless shitty remixes on the other hand are no more than fucking parasitism.  She got famous more or less on her own terms.  It was, albeit, with significant financial help from her label who saw someone with the beginnings of a product they could polish and whose goal was simply fame and would therefore presumably be obedient and pliable, but nevertheless Lizzy Grant is at least famous for being Lana Del Rey.  Which in the modern world is a kind of warped form of integrity I suppose.

The remixers on the other hand, or at least the herds of those who are suddenly remixing her songs, are bringing next to nothing to the fucking table.  She is famous, and they desperately want to put their name in brackets after hers in an mp3 tag in the contemptible hope that people looking for her might notice them clinging onto her skirts and that somehow by association someone might end up giving the tiniest fragment of a fuck about their worthless contribution to the world.

As a music blogger, my inbox is testament to this sort of parasitism.  When a band gets famous, particularly if they exhibit flash in the pan symptoms, or generate a degree of fevered hysteria which, love her or loathe her, Lana Del Rey most certainly did, you can be absolutely certain that I will see a depressing influx of two things: covers of their material, which is one of the reasons I am so very skeptical of cover versions, and a considerably more significant spike in remixes of their material.

And this inevitable flood of utter, exploitative, worthless garbage which floods the world of remixes makes me fucking despise the bastard things, and the people in music who encourage that sort of shit.  It’s leeching off other people’s skills, whilst contributing the bare minimum of anything at all to the world yourself, and it’s fucking pathetic.  And worse, there are good things to be done with remixes and good people who do them very, very well indeed, and I will probably never hear them now because the deluge of utter shit contaminating the term remix means I will never open another email which contains the word ever again.

Fucking do some actual creative work yourselves, you cunts, and stop exploiting other people’s skills and stop giving a bad name to the people who do that stuff well.

22 witty ripostes to Why Remixes Make Me Hate Music

  1. avatar

    Agree with pretty much all of this, nice post Matthew.

    I think part of the driver in all of this was the rise of the ‘laptop DJ’ around 2005/6 (which I was to some extent caught up in). It suddenly became very easy to beat match tracks and indie clubs started getting a lot more ‘dancey’ which in turn created the demand for free tracks with a dance beat and a recognisable hook. The proliferation of cracked versions of Ableton/Logic/Fruity Loops/whatever also probably had a fair bit to do with it.

  2. avatar

    Where do you stand on The XX remix of Florence & the Machine covering ‘you got the love’?

    I was going to put a link up but thought better of it.

  3. avatar

    This is brilliant. I agree wholeheartedly.

    It doesn’t just stop at remixes, though. There is an influx of bloggers (generally American) just posting the same as all the other bloggers for the hits. You can see their tiny little minds play catch-up on my Twitter stream.

    It really fucks me off because the reason I love(d) blogs so much is because bloggers are supposed to really fucking care. If you are just regurgitating shit hype songs for hits, you don’t really care about music. You care about hits. You aren’t a music fan. You are a ‘how many people can click on my blog today’ fan. It is just a soulless e-human centipede of i-whoring and I won’t fucking stand for it anymore.

  4. avatar

    “If you are just regurgitating shit hype songs for hits, you don’t really care about music.”

    This is why I despise news-farm blogs. If you don’t make money you are only doing it for the satisfaction, and if your only satisfaction is hit-whoring then clearly someone didn’t love you enough when you were a child.

  5. avatar

    I’m working on a remix right now. Get it up ye x

  6. avatar

    You always were a wrong ‘un, Common.

  7. avatar

    It is just a soulless e-human centipede of i-whoring and I won’t fucking stand for it anymore.

    1

  8. avatar

    Reminds me of a tale about Aphex Twin – at his peak commercially he was commissioned to remix a Lemonheads track (yeah, exactly why the f*ck would you want to remix the Lemonheads anyway).

    So, the record company arrive to pick up the remix and Aphex Twin realises he’s forgotten to do the remix. So he just gives them a half finished demo he’s been working on and tells them that’s the remix.

    The label go away happy, Aphex Twin gets paid – it’s a win-win.

    Except for the listener.

    Pretty much agree with everything you say here. Most remixes add no value to the track at all. Occasionally I’ll find one that I like and I’ll post that, but they are few and far between.

    Have to say, I’m always interested to hear 2 artists I like with one remixing the other though – just to see what they come up with.

  9. avatar

    You’re listening to the wrong remixes.

  10. avatar

    Yeah, but you did a remix album though Jonnie, didn’t ye?

    *ducks for cover*

  11. avatar

    Nothing strikes fear into my heart, and my finger hunting for the delete button, like the phrase “dubstep remix”. Stop it, everyone.

  12. avatar

    Matthew, this should make your day http://thequietus.com/articles/07752-listen-lana-del-rey-clams-casino

  13. avatar

    “Fucking do some actual creative work yourselves, you cunts, and stop exploiting other people’s skills and stop giving a bad name to the people who do that stuff well.” – well said. I think I’ve only heard maybe 2 or 3 remixes that are a significant improvement on the original version – considering the amount of remixes that are out there, that’s a pretty awful success rate.

  14. avatar

    Laurent, that link makes the little baby Jesus cry.

    Pop Cop (and others), yep it’s the landfill which drives me round the bend. I’ve heard an absolutely blindingly brilliant Jon Hopkins remix of Circle My Demise by King Creosote on one of the De-Fence 10″s, and some of the FOUND ones are genius, and there are plenty of others.

    It’s just frustrating as hell the extent to which they are drowned out by the deluge of shit, and so much of it made by people who simply do not seem to be doing it for respectable reasons at all.

  15. avatar

    I might also add that remixes can make significantly more or less sense depending on the kind of music as well.

  16. avatar

    Completely agree, and I think that as well as shitty remixers glueing themselves to hype tracks for attention a lot of the time it’s the PR companies equally to blame for piling on the madness. Say your big-ticket artist’s album isn’t out for a while, and she (no point pretending nobody knows who I’m on about) hasn’t released anything new you can send out to ensure she’s still what all the bloggers are talking about. Why don’t you send on some remixes and pretend it’s something new/noteworthy?

    Good thing bloggers aren’t stupid enough to fall for that shite, yes?

    Oh. Wait.

  17. avatar

    Bloggers being so prone to this sort of shit is a huge part of the problem. It wasn’t so bad in the UK, largely I think because blogs aren’t anything like as influential here as in the US, but now with Twitter it’s become a fucking nightmare.

    Now it’s not just bloggers being fucking idiots we have to contend with, but the general public as well. And we all know what they’re like.

  18. avatar

    The important thing is that you get the string on the guitar and you write a fucking song!-Barry Bliss

  19. avatar

    I remember a phrase the NME used back in the day, describing Armand Van Helden as “shamless remixer of anything that moves.” There are hundreds of thousands of Armand Van Heldens now.

  20. avatar

    You’re right about the complete lack of artistic merit in most of these remixes. And I speak as someone who counts remixes as among his favourite records. Problem also is the sheer quantity of shite hides the good ones. Bloggers need to be more discriminating too and not just act as clearing houses for their inbox.

  21. avatar

    Adam, there are so, so many bloggers who do that and I find it fucking pathetic, frankly. As Ian noted above they don’t just do it with remixes either, but with every pointless news piece handed to them by a label – copy, paste, publish. Hooray for the open internet allowing you to write if you really feel in your soul that you are a writer. Copy, paste, publish. James Joyce would be proud. Mind you, he was a pompous twat anyway, so he probably hated most things.

  22. avatar

    [...] agreed wholeheartedly with Matthew’s post, last week, on shit remixes – I’ve had my inbox polluted with enough of these, generally from PR companies with [...]

Leave a Reply

essay writing service