Regular podcast listeners (which is everyone, right?) will have heard of Magic Eye before. I’ve played them on a couple of podcasts I believe, and written about them on the blog before.
Well this is their first formal release, a tape called Shreddin’ on Heaven’s Floor which you can buy here, and I reckon it’s really rather promising.
My frame of reference for this kind of music is really rather limited, I have to confess. The only bands I’ve really listened to much in this kind of territory would be the like of Dubstar (who are more poppy), Stereloab (more weird and guitary) and perhaps the likes of the Cocteau Twins and certain aspects of Saint Etienne.
I’m going to be quite harsh on this EP, I think, but rest assured this is only because I think Magic Eye are a really good band who already have some cracking stuff, and who I think have the potential to do even better in the future. Put bluntly, though, I would chop this EP precisely in half.
When it’s good, this is really good – ethereal, dreamy pop songs with a beautifully jangly guitar shimmering alongside the gorgeous vocals. If that description sounds a little clichéd, then I suppose that’s probably fair enough, as for all words like those are overused when describing certain types of music in particular, in this case they are entirely appropriate.
So for all these songs, like a lot of things I am enjoying at the moment, are cut from a pretty familiar cloth, strong pop songs are strong pop songs and the first half of this EP glistens with promise. It is really quite slow, but that works well with this kind of minimal music, allowing every guitar chime and every elusive utterance to flutter to the ground, one at a time, like a scatter of descending feathers.
The side ends (unless I have my track listing wrong, which I may well because the mp3s weren’t very well tagged) with a cover of Chris Isaak’s Wicked Game. This is a risky strategy for a new band, as covering an established classic can easily overshadow your own songwriting, and make it pale somewhat by comparison, and whilst in this case it doesn’t really darken what went before, it does represent a height nothing subsequent manages to scale.
The second half contains a lot of the same aesthetic elements, but to my ears not quite the same quality of songwriting. The songs sound nice, but they don’t really grab me all that much, and I find my attention drifting. At eleven songs long, this could easily be an album though, and personally I think the band might have been better off editing it a little more brutally and just releasing four to six of their very strongest tunes, and leaving the rest for later.
Partly that would have made for a leaner, more concise release, partly they could have tested the waters with their audience without throwing absolutely everything out there, and partly there is never any harm in having extra songs up your sleeve.
Having said that, the first half of this (or the half a dozen or so tracks I might have randomly mistaken as the first half) is really good, and if they can build on that and progress then these guys have the potential to be very interesting indeed.
Audio clip: Adobe Flash Player (version 9 or above) is required to play this audio clip. Download the latest version here. You also need to have JavaScript enabled in your browser.
Website | More mp3s | Buy direct from the band