If I Didn’t Know These Folk, Would I Still Like Their Music?
This is a question no-one can answer of course, but the closer you get to bands and musicians the more relevant it becomes: how much is the actual music itself influencing how much I like music?
I never thought about it much, but I suppose it’s at its most evident when you go on holiday. Sitting on the beach in Southeast Asia I’ve found myself humming along to David Gray, reggae, even some truly awful chillout and, at the time, actually enjoying it.
I had an amazing time at Homegame, but I remember going along for the first time. This was something like 2006, and I didn’t really know anything about the Fence Collective nor indeed any of the bands other than James Yorkston and King Creosote. My sales pitch to Mrs. Toad to get her along was “Well a lot of the bands aren’t that great, but some of them are amazing, and it’s in a tiny Scottish fishing village for fuck’s sake, what could go wrong?”
I was right, of course, but I find myself wondering about that statement in retrospect. I have been consistently excited about the lineups over the last few years, and I ask myself a couple of questions. Firstly, is this just down to being more interested on DIY music these days, so I just know the bands better? Or, possibly, are the bills much the same quality, but I now know I am going to have such a good time that I ignore the bands on the bill I don’t like, focus on the good ones, and mentally fill in the gaps with Homegamefun and assume everything’s just brilliant?
Then there’s the personal side: I know lots of these bands personally by now, which must change things, but I don’t really know to what extent. There are loads of people who I personally like a great deal, and have shared many pints with, whose bands have never been so much as mentioned on these pages, so I clearly don’t just like stuff because I am pals with the band, but it must change something.
But when I think about dancing around like a pillock this weekend I do wonder, if I just heard the same stuff innocently on a stereo, would I enjoy it as much as I do now? I suppose I probably wouldn’t. My love for these bands is pretty impossible to separate from the amount of time I’ve spent leaping around like a muppet to their tunes, so surely if those things hadn’t happened it would take something away from my relationship with the music. I’m not sure what, but something.
I only bring this up because I wonder about explaining to people just how much fun Homegame actually is. I could do the ‘here, listen to this band and that band and the other band’, which I guess I do on Song, by Toad to an extent, but I doubt I could really put it across properly. And as you get more involved in music that gulf between bands who are just bands, and bands you develop quite involved relationships with for one reason or another just widens.
Of course if I hadn’t loved King Creosote and James Yorkston I would never have been drawn to Homegame, and if I hadn’t loved what I’d heard once I got there I wouldn’t have kept on returning. But there’s so much more to it now, it seems kind of unfair on ‘other music’ to even try and make a direct comparison. The fun of it comes from so many things – the manageable size making it so sociable, the new people you always end up meeting, the bands you’ve never seen before as much as the bands you’ve seen a dozen times, and of course the location and the whole annual ritual of it.
It’s a meaningless question of course. Music fits in with the rest of your life and it’s an interactive relationship, so your experience of everything depends on everything else, and you can get as much or as little out of music as you personally choose.
But I sometimes wonder what random pop-punk or experimental electronic band from just outside Wycombe I could have developed an equally joyous relationship with had we both just happened to be around at the right time and the right place.


Christ, people are getting this shit up and running early this year.


