Wilco – The Whole Love
I think I started to figure out what I wanted to write about this album when I read the following paragraph, which Euan wrote to introduce his own review on The Steinberg Principle:
“With ‘Sky Blue Sky’ and ‘Wilco (The Album)’, Wilco probably lost a lot of people who liked what they had done on ‘Yankee Hotel Foxtrot’ and ‘A Ghost Is Born’. I guess the same is true of those albums though, in that they lost a lot of people who loved ‘AM’, ‘Being There’ and ‘Summerteeth’ – or at least confused a lot.”
I think Euan found my tepid relationship with recent Wilco output a little frustrating, when we talked about it, because the first time we ever discussed Wilco was after Yankee Hotel Foxtrot and A Ghost is Born, and my love of those albums was equal to his, give or take. Then, when things changed on Sky Blue Sky, I just couldn’t love it anymore, however much I tried.
Mind you, the same thing happened when I discovered Summerteeth (which I bought because of the fantastic Billy Bragg collaborations, Mermaid Avenue Vol.1 and 2 which came out in the late 90s). I tried to explore backwards, and it just didn’t work. Try as I might, I just couldn’t get into A.M. or Being There, which was something I remember finding rather frustrating.
Looking back at Euan’s opening paragraph, I guess I was just one of those Wilco fans who remained stranded on the YHF/AGIB island, and that was just one of those things. It was kind of hard to accept though, given how much I loved those albums and, to a slightly lesser extent, Summerteeth. In a way I ended up with an elusive feeling of irritation, as if the band had failed me in some way, or as if I had failed them.
So with all that in mind, you’ll excuse me if I didn’t exactly leap to put this on the stereo when it plopped onto my doormat a couple of months ago. Partly, I think I was trying to avoid the anticipated guilt of not really liking it, but I’ve done my best to grow some balls, and I’m glad I did.
Not that this is an amazing album, inevitably. There are still some highly unwelcome hangovers from the classic/soft rock sludge of the previous two records, a sound I will never grow to love. Dawned on Me, for example, is just soft and squishy, and completely fails to excite. And it’s not alone.
I was inevitably a little put off the album by those familiar failings, however there were just enough moments to keep me around, little glimmers here and there of something a little different going on: the utterly gorgeous strings of Black Moon, for example, and the urgent machinery of epic opener Art of Almost.
An odd sense of persistence took hold as the good bits started to sink in. I still wasn’t enraptured with the album, but there was something which kept me going back. And for all I am still not enraptured with the album, I am really glad I have spent the time getting to know it better. Some of this is absolutely brilliant. The aforementioned Black Moon, for example, as well as the absolutely beautiful, piano-led, twelve-minute closer One Sunday Morning (Song for Jane Smiley’s Boyfriend), which might be one of the best songs they’ve ever written.
In between there are moments where the band recapture their old sprightliness, with songs which seem to be an odd mish-mash of YHF/AGIB era prog experimentalism and the more recent classic rock stodge, and yet sound oddly like they could almost be on Summerteeth. And while they are good, and there are just enough of them to make this album a good listen, it is those two sad songs I just mentioned which make me glad I made the time to listen to this album as much as I did. They are worth the price of admission alone.
Wilco – Black Moon
Audio clip: Adobe Flash Player (version 9 or above) is required to play this audio clip. Download the latest version here. You also need to have JavaScript enabled in your browser.
Audio clip: Adobe Flash Player (version 9 or above) is required to play this audio clip. Download the latest version here. You also need to have JavaScript enabled in your browser.









